Euask
A community for mutual assistance and knowledge sharing

Have your say on net neutrality. Reward $1
Created by nathanq, 37 days ago, 380 views

What do you think about net neutrality.
Facebook Twitter Google+ Addthis

√ Best Answer

1

ahmed5836 days ago

I think the answer to this essentially comes down to a few different factors.
1. What are subscriber fees paying for?
2. Is all data equal (and therefore should be billed the same)?
3. What is the right way to bill for data?

TL;DR. It depends. I think either position is fine, but the business practices and policies of the ISP should be consistent. Pick one and be fair about the position. Fees should reflect actual costs and a reasonable profit margin and should not allow anyone to get paid twice for the same service (though getting paid once with partial payments from multiple parties is fine).

Subscriber Fees
Based on what I've seen in ISP marketing literature, investor information, and through public FCC filings, the ISP's are claiming subscriber fees are the primary means they claim to fund maintenance and growth of internet service infrastructure.

Based on what I've seen in their public media statements, subscriber fees only cover a portion of internet service infrastructure.

I don't think either is an unreasonable position, but ISP business practices, governmental regulations, and internet-based businesses should consistently reflect one of those positions.

Today, it appears to me that they are trying to have it both ways and hide the fact they are actually getting paid twice. This would be similar to UPS charging the sender $15 and the receiver $10 for a delivery, but not telling either party that the other has paid a fee. Then, telling investors it actually costs $5 to deliver that package and the media that they're being abused by the receiver.

Data Equality
Another question is why video services should be singled out as paying for bandwidth, but not all other service? If the data is treated equally (that is, the data packet gets the same priority in their network as any other), shouldn't the data be billed at roughly equal cost (to whoever pays for it)?

Why is there a difference in the payment demands between downloading 1024 1MB pictures from a social network or photo service versus streaming a single 1024MB episode from a video service? Shouldn't both services be expected to pay the same cost for the same "strain" they put on ISP's?

(Obviously, this is a simplification and you can measure "strain" on a network different ways--MB's is just an example)

This issue becomes even more confusing where a customer is paying per GB. In essence, the ISP has said that a packet of data is the same "cost" regardless of the type of service or time of day. So in that case, shouldn't the fees paid by service providers be the same per GB (if any) regardless of the type of service?

Billing Data
Exactly what is the right way to charge for data? Peak bandwidth? Bytes of data transferred? Number of connections? Latency?

If the cost of infrastructure should be shared between subscribers and video service providers, what's the right way to account for the usage of of infrastructure?

ISP's charge their customers by max theoretical bandwidth (not actual bandwidth delivered) and number of bytes transmitted (up and down).

Transit providers charge by peak bandwidth actually consumed (not theoretical).

Data centers charge by ports and floor space (among other factors).

Peering costs are one of or some combination of the above or completely arbitrary (and usually secret between companies).

These methods of billing are not exactly interchangeable. So which one is the right way to account for the strain on infrastructure? And how do we make sure that ISP's aren't getting paid twice for the same service?

  • downvote

2

MAKEROFMONY236 days ago

hi
read this:http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42348041
or:https://aminoapps.com/c/creepypasta-amino-xx/page/blog/have-your-say-in-saving-net-neutrality/D8gl_J8KTPuLWBdPazwPXPYdEdegkK21330

  • downvote

3

nathanq36 days ago

@ahmed58
For future dont copy and paste someone elses post from a different website.
https://www.quora.com/What-do-you-think-of-net-neutrality

  • downvote
    You have to sign in to answer a question, sign up if you don't have an account.


    Hot Topics
    Alphonsus No problem just a question
    a454545 Release Port 80 For XAMPP
    ChessKing Which social network is better?
    omarwa The best aplication of video mantage
    Willith What is the best bluetooth transmitter?
    zagrebe Что с этим творить?
    raoulex Pour nettoyer mon ordinateur
    Recent users who have won rewards.
    Noth1ng1sSom3th1ng won $1
    FixitJorge won $1
    MAKEROFMONY2 won $1
    thsigit won $1
    ab1936 won $1
    ahmed58 won $1
    chakramed won $1
    ha14 won $5
    chakramed won $1
    ha14 won $1
    Latest Topics
    CarloCorbacelli 1 f... pc 2 lic driver c 5 wise care
    omarwa The best aplication of video mantage
    MarkusTwaine Cеверный Мост материнской платы
    Alphonsus No problem just a question
    Misterheri What is the best free apk to make my own Crosswords Puzzle?
    raoulex Pour nettoyer mon ordinateur
    ChessKing Which social network is better?
    zagrebe Что с этим творить?
    startuparena Alexa Ranking Problem
    a454545 Release Port 80 For XAMPP
    Get free dollars by installing euask App.